There’s a pervasive mood that China has the upper hand in the tariff stand-off with the United States. China certainly has cards to play. Its very small RMB devaluation in April - when US tariffs briefly touched 150 percent - sparked disorder in the Treasury market and got the US to bring tariffs back down. It’s obviously got a stranglehold on rare earths as well, which is giving it bargaining power.
But the narrative that China is impervious to US tariffs is wrong. You just have to look at the massive scale of trade diversion that’s happening to see that, which is pushing China into deep deflation. Moreover, the world is financially decoupling from China, with foreign direct investment (FDI) flows falling more precipitously than to the rest of emerging markets (EM), while trends in foreign portfolio flows and other investment flows also point in the same direction. The former are flows into Chinese stocks and bonds, while the latter are bank-intermediated flows like trade finance and cross-border loans.
This financial decoupling predates this year’s tariffs and is a longer-running trend that emerged after COVID. I’m personally convinced that Russia’s invasion of Ukraine plays a role, because foreign investors fear a similar move by China on Taiwan. But - obviously - it’s impossible to say with certainty what’s driving capital flows in any given moment. I lay out the capital flows data in today’s post.
The four charts above compare non-resident flows into China across the three main categories in the balance of payments: (i) FDI flows; (ii) portfolio flows; and (iii) other investment flows. The top left chart shows the sum across these three categories for China (black line) and an aggregate across 24 of the world’s biggest EMs (blue line). This chart makes clear that something clearly changed after COVID. As flows to the rest of EM rebounded, flows to China are basically flat. The only historical parallel is the 2015/6 RMB devaluation scare, but there’s obviously nothing similar going on now.
The subsequent three charts show FDI flows (top right), portfolio flows (bottom left) and other investment flows (bottom right). FDI flows - excluding reinvested earnings - are at their weakest level ever, but this is a continuation of a longer-running trend without a clear catalyst like Ukraine or tariffs. Portfolio flows seem to be decoupling more recently, with tariffs a potential catalyst. Other investment flows have most obviously reacted negatively to the Ukraine invasion. Across all these, the picture is clear. The world is financially retrenching from China.


Hi Robin,
As always a great post!
Minor correction on your last sentence…”Across all these, the picture is clear. The world is financially retrenching from Ukraine.” You really meant CHINA not Ukraine.
Cheers,
John