Could you enlighten me in terms of the amount of Japanese government asset that is available to sell? It looks like that there are not a lot and may not be possible to sell e.g. roads and bridges, as the Japan MoF puts it. It would be very helpful if you could shed some light on this.
Robin Brooks is spot on in the diagnosis of disequilibrium in the foreign exchange market with Japanese Yen on a path to devalue against the U.S. dollar and other foreign currencies. The unconventional monetary policy of BOJ keeping longterm yields of JGBs too low for too long has caused this disequilibrium and it is now unwinding. I agree with Brooks that the unwinding of it will further continue in defiance of the joint intervention by the U.S. Treasury and Japan’s Ministry of Finance.
US treasuries, public debt. Selling those to reverse JPY weakness would in turn cause US rates to rise which is probably why the USG recently coordinated the market intervention with the GOJ.
Shouldn't the financial markets value the yen based on net debt, not gross debt? A person with $100 in a Tokyo bank has the same wealth as someone with $50 in Tokyo and $50 in NY, yes? (Or, to put it differently, it shouldn't matter whether you slice the pizza into four slices or eight.)
1. Severe Valuation Mispricing (Extreme Purchasing Power Parity Disconnect)
Mellon views the Yen as "crazily undervalued" against major developed currencies, particularly the U.S. Dollar.
He views the decades-long weakness of the Yen—exacerbated by extended period yield differentials—as an unsustainable distortion rather than a reflect of underlying economic weight.
Relative to real purchasing power parity (PPP), he argues that the Yen has traded at historically depressed levels, leaving immense upside room for a mean-reversion move.
The Repatriation & Domestic Saver Catalyst
A critical dynamic in Mellon’s thesis is the potential for unwinding foreign holdings by Japanese institutional and retail investors.
Japanese domestic capital holds massive positions in U.S. treasuries, equities, and overseas assets.
Mellon argues that even a minor shift in sentiment or anxiety over high U.S. asset valuations and an overvalued Dollar will trigger a wave of repatriation back into Japan.
Once Japanese capital begins heading home, the massive influx of Dollar selling and Yen buying could tip the currency into a rapid, self-reinforcing upward trajectory
“Only higher yields can stabilize the yen”. I think you might want to examine stock adjustment portfolio balance models and exchange rate overshooting.
If Japan’s net debt cushion is really the escape hatch, the real test isn’t whether that asset sale gets announced — it’s whether markets are willing to wait for it before the shadow yield gap gets priced in anyway.
Just now read elsewhere that Japanese assets include a great deal of US debt, and that we are facilitating intervention because Japan shedding US debt would be a disaster for the US. Comments?
I think what is important is seeing what percentage of Japanese bonds are held by foreigners.
If most of the Japanese debt is held by Japanese nationals or by BOJ, then, this missallocation could be maintained much longer, with long term yields bellow where they should be, and a stronger yen than it should be.
The USA defeated Japan 🇯🇵 in what 1945? Somethings never change. The USA will do a lot to prevent Japan from selling Treasuries so they are between a rock 🪨 and a hard place. They have done QE longer than anyone on earth and created the ultimate carry trade and they bought massive USG securities to accommodate the USA. They have all this low interest rate government and private debt and if rates rise to true market the interest rate will be crushing.
So how navigate this thicket of forces ?
Maybe a long term long time program to increase rates. Slowly but steadily and restructuring of all the zombie balance sheets. Japan is one of the last huge holders of USTs as the rest of the world lightens up
Could you enlighten me in terms of the amount of Japanese government asset that is available to sell? It looks like that there are not a lot and may not be possible to sell e.g. roads and bridges, as the Japan MoF puts it. It would be very helpful if you could shed some light on this.
Robin Brooks is spot on in the diagnosis of disequilibrium in the foreign exchange market with Japanese Yen on a path to devalue against the U.S. dollar and other foreign currencies. The unconventional monetary policy of BOJ keeping longterm yields of JGBs too low for too long has caused this disequilibrium and it is now unwinding. I agree with Brooks that the unwinding of it will further continue in defiance of the joint intervention by the U.S. Treasury and Japan’s Ministry of Finance.
Maybe a stupid question, what assets do they hold?
US treasuries, public debt. Selling those to reverse JPY weakness would in turn cause US rates to rise which is probably why the USG recently coordinated the market intervention with the GOJ.
Shouldn't the financial markets value the yen based on net debt, not gross debt? A person with $100 in a Tokyo bank has the same wealth as someone with $50 in Tokyo and $50 in NY, yes? (Or, to put it differently, it shouldn't matter whether you slice the pizza into four slices or eight.)
Would make sense but the US treasuries are not liquid. Until they are!
When I wrote my question, I had not noticed John Higgins post. Is his post the reason?
Why are the Japanese in denial about the fix for the yen? Selling 10% of assets seems a simple thing to do without grave consequences.
1. Severe Valuation Mispricing (Extreme Purchasing Power Parity Disconnect)
Mellon views the Yen as "crazily undervalued" against major developed currencies, particularly the U.S. Dollar.
He views the decades-long weakness of the Yen—exacerbated by extended period yield differentials—as an unsustainable distortion rather than a reflect of underlying economic weight.
Relative to real purchasing power parity (PPP), he argues that the Yen has traded at historically depressed levels, leaving immense upside room for a mean-reversion move.
The Repatriation & Domestic Saver Catalyst
A critical dynamic in Mellon’s thesis is the potential for unwinding foreign holdings by Japanese institutional and retail investors.
Japanese domestic capital holds massive positions in U.S. treasuries, equities, and overseas assets.
Mellon argues that even a minor shift in sentiment or anxiety over high U.S. asset valuations and an overvalued Dollar will trigger a wave of repatriation back into Japan.
Once Japanese capital begins heading home, the massive influx of Dollar selling and Yen buying could tip the currency into a rapid, self-reinforcing upward trajectory
“Only higher yields can stabilize the yen”. I think you might want to examine stock adjustment portfolio balance models and exchange rate overshooting.
I'll defer to Robin but Japanese government is a majority owner of the Bank of Japan who own, in aggregate, ~10% of the Nikkei
Duly noted
USDJPY 180
If Japan’s net debt cushion is really the escape hatch, the real test isn’t whether that asset sale gets announced — it’s whether markets are willing to wait for it before the shadow yield gap gets priced in anyway.
Just now read elsewhere that Japanese assets include a great deal of US debt, and that we are facilitating intervention because Japan shedding US debt would be a disaster for the US. Comments?
I think what is important is seeing what percentage of Japanese bonds are held by foreigners.
If most of the Japanese debt is held by Japanese nationals or by BOJ, then, this missallocation could be maintained much longer, with long term yields bellow where they should be, and a stronger yen than it should be.
Maybe a stupid question, what assets do they hold?
The USA defeated Japan 🇯🇵 in what 1945? Somethings never change. The USA will do a lot to prevent Japan from selling Treasuries so they are between a rock 🪨 and a hard place. They have done QE longer than anyone on earth and created the ultimate carry trade and they bought massive USG securities to accommodate the USA. They have all this low interest rate government and private debt and if rates rise to true market the interest rate will be crushing.
So how navigate this thicket of forces ?
Maybe a long term long time program to increase rates. Slowly but steadily and restructuring of all the zombie balance sheets. Japan is one of the last huge holders of USTs as the rest of the world lightens up
This is a tough one