Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Matthew Edwards's avatar

I've thought you've made convincing cases, particularly around Russia post-2022, that sanctions can work and cause asymmetric economic pain.

What I'm not convinced is that asymmetric economic pain wins wars. Iraq in the 1990s is the classic example of sanctions causing a huge amount of suffering (and enabling corruption and scandals) and the regime staying in power until a convention war removed it.

Similarly, Iran's people are absolutely suffering but is that effectively changing policy at the top?

I'm not familiar with the literature on blockades on Japan or Germany through WW2, but in both cases absolutely brutal civilian suffering was exacerbated by sending resources to the armed forces who were only defeated by 1) total occupation and 2) nuclear bombings/soviets entering the war.

Not sure you do reader requests, or even better if it's already been covered, but I would appreciate a post on why you think economic coercion works.

Vitaily Liberman's avatar

Program’s effectiveness has to be judged by the stated goal, nothing else. The only stated goal I could glean from presentation by Bessent is that of regime change. If that is so, none of your charts address the possibility or probability of achieving such goal. Further, in many cases, such draconian economic collapse serves to strengthen regime.

On the economic front, Pakistan is as important as Turkey and most sanctions avoiding trade with China is done via that route. Goods can enter Pakistan through ports such as Karachi, Port Qasim, or Gwadar, then move by truck toward the Pakistan–Iran border. Pakistan reportedly opened six overland routes for third-country cargo transiting from those ports to Iran in 2026.

Unless US is willing to engage military with nuclear Pakistan, that trade will continue.

So no, proposed sanctions will do nothing to change leadership in Iran.

40 more comments...

Ready for more?